I’ve started a lot of businesses over the years.

And when I say a lot, I mean enough that I could probably create an organizational chart for Hoskins Holdings and assign myself a different executive title for every failed venture.

At least then I’d have something to show for all of them.

I’ve sold products. I’ve offered services. I’ve made things with my own two hands. I’ve invested thousands of dollars, countless hours, and more hope than I probably should have.

And almost every single time, it started the same way.

“You’d be so good at that!”

“You should totally sell those!”

“People would pay good money for that!”

“You should start your own business!”

And you know what?

I believed them.

Not because I’m gullible. Not because I thought starting a business would be easy. And certainly not because I expected to become an overnight millionaire.

I believed them because I knew I was good at what I was doing. I had something worthwhile to offer. And when the people around me encouraged me to pursue it, I thought maybe they saw that, too.

So I did it.

I invested the money. I bought the supplies. I created the products. I built the websites. I learned the software. I figured out the logistics. I showed up.

And then I waited for everyone else to show up, too. And I’m still waiting.

The Business That Hurt the Most

Of all the businesses I’ve tried over the last twelve years, there’s one that still hurts more than any of the others.

Sugar Shack Bake Shop.

I loved baking. And I don’t mean I enjoyed occasionally throwing a batch of chocolate chip cookies in the oven.

I mean I genuinely, wholeheartedly loved baking.

I loved scrolling Pinterest looking for recipes. I loved coming up with flavor combinations and then figuring out how to make them work.

Chocolate peanut butter. Cookies and cream. Biscoff cookie butter. Lemon blueberry.

I loved experimenting. I loved decorating. Hell, I even loved piping icing onto cupcakes.

I know. I’m weird.

I once learned a technique where you flip frosted cupcakes upside down onto wax paper and freeze them so the tops come out perfectly smooth. Then you can decorate them however you want.

I used that trick to make a bullseye cupcake cake for the archery group at church.

I was ridiculously proud of that thing. And I loved watching people eat what I made.

There’s something incredibly satisfying about spending hours creating something and then watching someone take that first bite.

The compliments were nice, too. I’m not going to pretend otherwise.

But it wasn’t just about compliments. It was about creating something.

Something that was mine. Something I was genuinely good at. Something that made me happy.

For years, I was the person who brought dessert to family gatherings. It was my thing.

I knew what people liked. I knew which flavors disappeared first. I knew who loved chocolate, who preferred peanut butter, and which combinations would have people coming back for seconds.

I even made the desserts for a family wedding.

Over 100 cupcakes and a small wedding cake.

It was a huge undertaking, but I loved every minute of it.

And everyone loved the desserts.

So when people started encouraging me to turn baking into a business, it seemed like a natural next step.

I was already doing the work. People already enjoyed what I made.

Why not try to earn a little money doing something I loved?

Apparently, that changed things.

When Free Became Too Expensive

Here’s the part I’ve never really talked about.

For years, I was the person who brought desserts to gatherings, celebrations, and special occasions.

I loved doing it.

Sometimes that meant a batch of cookies. Sometimes it meant cake or cupcakes. And sometimes it meant spending hours in the kitchen creating something elaborate for someone I cared about.

I didn’t charge for those things because I wasn’t doing them as a business. I was doing them because I wanted to.

But when I decided to turn baking into a business, something changed.

Suddenly, I wasn’t just the person who loved making desserts. I was someone trying to put a price on something I’d spent years giving away.

And honestly, I don’t think I was prepared for how difficult that transition would be.

The orders I hoped would come never really materialized.

Over time, I also found myself baking less and less for the occasions where I’d once been the person everyone counted on for dessert.

Some of that was simply life changing. Other people discovered a love for baking. My gastric sleeve surgery made it difficult for me to enjoy the process the way I once had. And eventually, I stepped away from baking almost entirely.

But even understanding those things, I struggled with the feeling that something I’d loved doing had quietly slipped away.

And I cannot begin to explain how much that hurt.

I know this probably sounds ridiculous. It’s dessert. It’s cake and cookies and cupcakes.

There are far bigger things in the world to be upset about.

But it wasn’t just dessert to me.

It was something I loved doing. Something I contributed. Something that made me feel like I had a special little place in the lives of people I cared about.

And when that changed, I didn’t really know what to do with the feelings that came with it.

I didn’t understand them then. I’m not sure I completely understand them now.

And I want to be clear about something.

Nobody owes me their business simply because they know me or because we’re related.

They don’t.

People are allowed to choose where they spend their money, who they purchase from, and what they want to serve at their own gatherings.

I understand that. But there’s a difference between understanding something logically and understanding why it hurts so damn much.

Because somewhere along the way, I started wondering why the things I had spent years doing for free seemed so difficult to turn into something people would pay for.

Was I expecting too much? Was I putting too much value on something other people viewed differently? Had I spent so long giving things away that I’d unintentionally taught people my time wasn’t worth paying for?

Was I the problem? (There’s that pesky question again.)

I still don’t know.

What I do know is that the experience left me feeling discouraged, unappreciated, and honestly, a little rejected.

Not because someone else was making dessert.

But because something that had brought me so much happiness had become tangled up with feelings I didn’t know how to process.

And instead of talking about it, I just stopped baking.

I told myself I didn’t have the time. That surgery had made it too difficult. That there wasn’t enough demand to make it worthwhile.

And all of those things were true to some extent.

But I think there was also a part of me that simply didn’t want to keep putting something I loved out into the world only to feel disappointed by the response.

So I packed away the piping bags, the decorating tips, and the cupcake pans.

And somewhere along the way, I stopped doing one of the things that had always made me genuinely happy.

It Wasn’t Just Baking

The more I think about it, the more I realize this pattern has followed me through several different businesses.

Scentsy.

Advocare.

LegacyMakerCo.

On Target Bookkeeping Solutions.

On Target Tax Services.

Sugar Shack Bake Shop.

Some were network marketing businesses where I spent thousands of dollars purchasing inventory to meet minimums, hoping I could turn around and sell enough to make the investment worthwhile.

Spoiler alert: I couldn’t.

I still have Scentsy wax bars sitting in a closet somewhere.

My husband couldn’t stand the scents, so I couldn’t even use half the stuff I bought.

And a lot of the Advocare products eventually ended up in the garbage.

Then there was LegacyMakerCo.

I made Ribbon Pops, these adorable little ribbon keychains with beads and different themes.

Sports teams. School colors. Teachers. Christmas.

I had ribbon, beads, clasps, string, glue, storage containers, and enough craft supplies to open my own miniature Hobby Lobby.

I even bought a Cricut Maker when I expanded into other projects.

And I genuinely enjoyed making things.

I made Ribbon Pops for my daughter’s volleyball team, and the girls loved them. They kept them on their backpacks.

People would stop at craft shows, pick them up, admire them, and tell me how adorable they were. And then put them back down.

Over and over again.

I got really good at hearing how much people loved something while watching them walk away without buying it.

And I know that sounds bitter. Maybe it is.

But after spending hundreds of dollars on materials and hours creating products, compliments didn’t exactly pay for the supplies.

Then there were the bookkeeping and tax businesses.

Those were different because I wasn’t selling a physical product.

I was selling my knowledge. My education. My experience. My professional skills.

And somehow, that created an entirely different problem.

People wanted the services. They just didn’t necessarily want to pay for them.

Being Good at Something Doesn’t Mean Anyone Will Pay You for It

The more I look back at these experiences, the more I realize that I spent years confusing two very different things.

Being good at something. And being able to build a successful business around it.

I thought that if I worked hard enough, created something worthwhile, and offered people something they genuinely needed or enjoyed, the rest would eventually fall into place.

And professionally, I’ve seen what hard work can accomplish.

I can take a financial mess, dig through years of transactions, find discrepancies, rebuild records, and create systems that actually make sense. I can identify problems and develop solutions. I can build something from absolutely nothing.

Give me a complicated problem and enough time, and I’ll probably figure out a way to solve it.

It’s one of the things I genuinely like about myself.

But there’s something nobody really prepares you for when you start a business.

You can be incredibly good at what you do and still not have customers.

You can create a fantastic product that nobody buys. You can offer a valuable service that nobody wants to pay for. You can spend weeks developing a system that someone else decides they don’t need. You can pour your heart into something and watch other people shrug their shoulders and move on.

And there’s not a damn thing you can do about it. Because you cannot make people appreciate what you’ve created.

You cannot make them see its value the same way you do. And you certainly cannot make them choose you.

That’s been a particularly difficult realization for me.

Because I’ve always believed that if I worked hard enough, the results would speak for themselves.

What I never considered was that people could recognize the value of something and still choose not to support it.

Or that they could genuinely admire what I created without needing or wanting to purchase it. Or that they could encourage me to pursue something without ever intending to become part of making it successful.

I don’t think everyone who encouraged me was being dishonest. I think most people genuinely meant what they said.

But encouragement and actual support are two very different things. And I didn’t understand how painful that difference could be until I’d experienced it repeatedly.

Twelve Years of Trying

I wish I could tell you that all these experiences made me stronger. That I learned valuable lessons, dusted myself off, and confidently moved on to the next adventure.

And sure, I’ve learned things.

I’ve learned that inventory is expensive. I’ve learned that having a creative idea doesn’t automatically mean there’s a market for it. I’ve learned that people will compliment something they have absolutely no intention of purchasing. I’ve learned that family and business can be an uncomfortable combination. And I’ve learned that just because I can do something doesn’t mean I should do it for free.

But I’ve also learned something I really wish I hadn’t.

I’ve learned to be afraid of trying. And I hate admitting that.

Because I’m not someone who typically shies away from a challenge.

I’m the person who sees a problem and immediately starts figuring out how to solve it. I’m the person who gets excited about building systems, creating processes, and turning an idea into something real.

I’m a planner. An analyst. An overthinker.

Give me enough information, and I’ll build a spreadsheet to predict just about anything. But I cannot build a spreadsheet that guarantees people will buy what I’m selling.

And that absolutely terrifies me.

Because after twelve years of trying different things, spending money we couldn’t necessarily afford to lose, and watching business after business fail to become what I’d hoped?

I’ve stopped believing in myself the way I used to.

There. I said it.

I know I’m capable. I know I have valuable skills. I know I can produce quality work.

But I don’t trust myself to turn those things into a successful business anymore.

And that’s a really shitty feeling.

And Here I Go Again

I’m currently building Anchor Accounting Solutions. And I am genuinely excited about it.

I’ve been developing an Accounting Diagnostic Method that takes the kind of detailed financial cleanup work I do professionally and turns it into a structured process.

I’m creating forms, pricing tools, workflows, and eventually, I hope, training materials that could teach other people how to perform these kinds of in-depth accounting cleanups.

I can see the potential. My husband can see the potential. I can see how businesses with messy financial records could benefit from having someone figure out what went wrong and how to fix it. I can see how other bookkeepers and accountants might benefit from learning a more structured approach to cleanup work.

I know what I’m building has value. But there’s this voice in the back of my head that won’t shut up.

What if nobody wants it?

What if I spend months creating everything, getting it exactly how I want it, building out the systems, developing the materials, and preparing to launch?

And nobody shows up?

Again.

What if I put another piece of myself into something that fails? What if I get excited, start believing this could finally be the thing that works, and end up disappointed all over again?

I don’t want to go through that again. I really don’t.

And I think that fear is starting to affect me more than I’ve wanted to admit.

Some days I sit down to work on Anchor and I’m excited. I have ideas coming faster than I can write them down.

Other days I stare at everything I’ve started building and can’t make myself work on any of it.

Because somewhere in the back of my mind, I’m wondering whether I’m wasting my time. Again.

It’s not that I don’t believe in the work. It’s that I’m terrified of believing in what the work could become.

Because I’ve been here before. I’ve been excited before. I’ve been encouraged before. I’ve believed that something could work before.

And I’ve watched it not work. Over and over again.

I Miss the Version of Me Who Just Created Things

Earlier today, while talking through all of this, I started thinking about baking again.

Not the business. Not the customers. Not the disappointment.

Just baking.

I started remembering how much I loved experimenting with flavors and decorating cupcakes.

How much I enjoyed trying new recipes. How excited I used to get when I came up with something I wanted to make.

And I realized how much I miss it.

I haven’t really baked like that in almost three years.

Part of that was because of my gastric sleeve surgery. After surgery, tasting sugary batters and frostings made me sick, and it became difficult to bake the way I used to.

But somewhere along the way, the disappointment surrounding the business became tangled up with something I had genuinely loved doing.

And I stopped.

Today, I decided I wanted to make Biscoff cookie butter mini cheesecakes.

Not because someone ordered them. Not because I wanted to sell them. Not because I was trying to prove anything.

Just because I had an idea and thought they’d taste amazing.

I went to the grocery store, bought the ingredients, and came home excited to make them.

Then I realized I’d forgotten the heavy whipping cream. Because apparently even my attempt to rediscover a hobby needs a minor logistical complication.

So cheesecake night has been postponed until the weekend.

Naturally.

But here’s the thing. I’m still excited to make them. And I haven’t felt that kind of excitement about baking in a long time.

I’m not sure what that means yet. Maybe nothing.

Maybe I’ll make some cheesecakes, my family will eat them, and that’ll be the end of it. Maybe I’ll start baking more often. Maybe someday I’ll decide to sell something again.

I don’t know.

And for once, I’m trying not to turn the entire thing into a business plan before I’ve even made the first batch.

Which, if you know me, is a pretty significant accomplishment.

I Don’t Know How to Believe Again

I wish I could end this by telling you I’ve figured out how to stop being afraid of failure.

That I’ve realized other people’s support doesn’t determine my worth. That I’m going to launch Anchor Accounting Solutions with complete confidence and never look back.

But that’s not where I am.

I’m still hurt by things that happened years ago. I’m still frustrated by how often I’ve given my time and skills away. I’m still trying to understand why people will pay someone else for something they expected me to provide for free. I’m still disappointed by businesses I genuinely believed could succeed.

And I’m still terrified that Anchor will become another name on the growing list of things I tried that didn’t work.

I know people mean well when they tell me I can do anything I put my mind to.

But I’ve put my mind to a lot of things. I’ve worked hard. I’ve sacrificed. I’ve invested money. I’ve invested time. I’ve believed.

And most of them it still wasn’t enough.

That’s the part I wish more people understood.

I don’t need someone to tell me I’m capable of building something.

I already know I can build it.

What I don’t know is whether anyone will want what I’ve built.

And after twelve years of trying, I’m not sure how many more times I can get excited about something, put everything I have into it, and watch it go nowhere.

I want Anchor to succeed. I want to believe that this time could be different. I want to feel excited about the possibilities without immediately calculating how much it’s going to hurt if they don’t happen.

But right now, every time I start imagining what this business could become, another part of my brain starts preparing for what happens if it fails.

And I hate that.

I hate that something I used to approach with excitement now comes with so much fear. I hate that I’ve started questioning myself before I’ve even given this business a chance. And I hate that after everything I’ve learned, everything I’ve accomplished, and everything I know I’m capable of doing, I’m still sitting here wondering whether anyone will ever believe in something I’ve created enough to actually pay for it.

Everyone told me I could. And I believed them.

I just wish more people understood what it feels like to keep showing up for something you believe in, only to look around and realize you’re standing there alone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *